{"vuln_id":"GHSA-69q9-v8p6-xvx3","aliases":[],"description":"Revoked or unconfirmed organization member retains read and delete access to organization ciphers","published_at":"2026-10-28T18:01:21Z","modified_at":"2026-10-28T18:01:21Z","first_seen_at":"2026-11-22T13:40:16.266013Z","severity":"high","severity_source":"ghsa","cvss_score":8.1,"cvss_vector":"CVSS:3.1/AV:N/AC:L/PR:L/UI:N/S:U/C:H/I:H/A:N","cwe":["CWE-863"],"vendor":null,"product":null,"kev":{"is_kev":false,"date_added":null,"due_date":null,"ransomware":false},"epss":null,"epss_percentile":null,"nvd_status":null,"enriched_at":null,"links":{"nvd":"https://github.com/advisories/GHSA-69q9-v8p6-xvx3"},"matched_alias":null,"items":[{"id":12035,"source":{"id":"gh-vaultwarden","name":"Vaultwarden releases + advisories (GitHub dani-garcia/vaultwarden)"},"title":"GHSA-69q9-v8p6-xvx3: Revoked or unconfirmed organization member retains read and delete access to organization ciphers","summary":"Revoked or unconfirmed organization member retains read and delete access to organization ciphers\n\n## Summary\r\n\r\nRevoking an organization member suspends them in the UI and hides organization items from their\r\nsync, but does not remove the collection and group grants that the per-item authorization checks\r\nrely on. A revoked member who keeps their own account can continue to read organization ciphers\r\none at a time, and can soft-delete and permanently delete them, indefinitely. The item-level checks\r\nnever consult membership status, while the listing queries do.\r\n\r\n## Severity / CVSS\r\n\r\nCVSS 3.1 vector: `CVSS:3.1/AV:N/AC:L/PR:L/UI:N/S:U/C:H/I:H/A:N`\r\nBase score: 8.1\r\nSeverity: High\r\n\r\n`PR:L` because the attacker authenticates with their own surviving account, which revocation does\r\nnot disable. `C:H` for continued read access to organization secrets, including secrets rotated in\r\nplace after the revocation. `I:H` for permanent destruction of organization items; editing item\r\ncontents is blocked by a separate check, so this metric covers deletion only. `A:N` because the\r\nservice itself is unaffected.\r\n\r\n## Affected component\r\n\r\n- `src/db/models/cipher.rs`, `Cipher::get_access_restrictions`,\r\n  `get_user_collections_access_flags`, `get_group_collections_access_flags`\r\n- `src/db/models/group.rs`, `Group::is_in_full_access_group`\r\n- `src/api/core/organizations.rs`, `revoke_member_impl`\r\n- `src/api/core/ciphers.rs`, `get_cipher`, `delete_cipher_by_uuid`, `restore_cipher_by_uuid`,\r\n  `delete_cipher_attachment_by_id`\r\n\r\nTested at commit `46ae59eaf444f0ae0a799070cf2bd6c415284a51`, default configuration, sqlite,\r\nmail disabled.\r\n\r\n## Root cause\r\n\r\nRevocation adjusts the status field and saves the row:\r\n\r\n```rust\r\n// organizations.rs:2338, revoke_member_impl\r\nmember.revoke();          // status -= 128\r\nmember.save(conn).await?;\r\n```\r\n\r\n`Membership::save` (`organization.rs:752`) writes the membership row and nothing else. The removal\r\npath, `Membership::delete` (`organization.rs:785`), does tear down the derived grants:\r\n\r\n```rust\r\nCollectionUser::delete_all_by_user_and_org(&self.user_uuid, &self.org_uuid, conn).await?;\r\nGroupUser::delete_all_by_member(&self.uuid, conn).await?;\r\n```\r\n\r\nRevocation performs neither, so the `users_collections` and `groups_users` rows survive.\r\n\r\nThe listing queries compensate by filtering on membership status. `Cipher::find_by_user` joins\r\n`users_organizations` under `status = Confirmed` and then constrains the collection join to that\r\nmembership:\r\n\r\n```rust\r\n// cipher.rs:814-825\r\n.left_join(\r\n    users_organizations::table.on(ciphers::organization_uuid\r\n        .eq(users_organizations::org_uuid.nullable())\r\n        .and(users_organizations::user_uuid.eq(user_uuid))\r\n        .and(users_organizations::status.eq(MembershipStatus::Confirmed as i32))),\r\n)\r\n.left_join(\r\n    users_collections::table.on(ciphers_collections::collection_uuid\r\n        .eq(users_collections::collection_uuid)\r\n        // Ensure that users_collections::user_uuid is NULL for unconfirmed users.\r\n        .and(users_organizations::user_uuid.eq(users_collect\n\nAffected packages: rust:vaultwarden\nPatched: vaultwarden 1.37.4","url":"https://github.com/dani-garcia/vaultwarden/security/advisories/GHSA-69q9-v8p6-xvx3","published_at":"2026-10-28T18:01:21Z","updated_at":"2026-10-28T18:01:21Z","fetched_at":"2026-11-22T13:40:16.224693Z","severity":"high","cvss_score":8.1,"epss":null,"is_kev":false,"has_exploit":false,"kev_due_date":null,"vendor":"dani-garcia","product":"vaultwarden","vuln_id":"GHSA-69q9-v8p6-xvx3","vuln_ids":["GHSA-69Q9-V8P6-XVX3"],"tags":["repo-advisory","rust","CWE-863","security","repo:dani-garcia/vaultwarden"],"cluster_id":11344,"links":{"self":"https://vulnwatch.ve1ve2.com/api/v1/items/12035","html":"https://vulnwatch.ve1ve2.com/item/12035"}},{"id":12065,"source":{"id":"gh-vaultwarden","name":"Vaultwarden releases + advisories (GitHub dani-garcia/vaultwarden)"},"title":"[SECURITY RELEASE] dani-garcia/vaultwarden 1.37.4","summary":"Fixes advisories: GHSA-7ccc-c43j-4p36, GHSA-69q9-v8p6-xvx3, GHSA-q5x6-grh5-fqgc, GHSA-v576-3wvq-xh3c, GHSA-64mc-4p6f-r7x9, GHSA-qwx4-wcv4-mpcv, GHSA-7jg8-8m5x-6j9r\n\nSecurity keywords: security, GHSA-69Q9-V8P6-XVX3, GHSA-7JG8-8M5X-6J9R, GHSA-V576-3WVQ-XH3C, GHSA-Q5X6-GRH5-FQGC, GHSA-64MC-4P6F-R7X9, GHSA-7CCC-C43J-4P36, GHSA-QWX4-WCV4-MPCV\n\nSecurity Fixes\n\nThis release contains security fixes for the following advisories. We strongly advise updating as soon as possible.\n\nOrganization member revocation [GHSA-69q9-v8p6-xvx3] (High, 8.1)\n\nTwo-factor authentication [GHSA-7jg8-8m5x-6j9r] (Medium, 6.8)\n\nOrganization invitations [GHSA-v576-3wvq-xh3c] (Medium, 6.8)\n\nAttachments [GHSA-q5x6-grh5-fqgc] (Medium, 6.5)\n\nOrganization event logs [GHSA-64mc-4p6f-r7x9] (Medium, 4.3)\n\nCipher sharing [GHSA-7ccc-c43j-4p36] (Medium, 4.3)\n\nOrganization API key [GHSA-qwx4-wcv4-mpcv] (Low, 3.8)\n\nAdditional dependency updates and minor security enhancements\n\nThese are private for now, pending CVE assignment and publishing at a later date.\n\nNote\n\nIf an organization has Admins you don't fully trust, consider rotating its API key after updating (Admin Console → Settings → Rotate API key). Before this release, Admins could also view the key.\n\nUpgrade notes\n\nReverse proxies: with IP_HEADER=X-Forwarded-For, the client IP is now the rightmost address that isn't in IP_HEADER_TRUSTED_PROXIES (it used to be the leftmost). If you have several proxies in a row, for example a CDN in front of nginx, add all of them to IP_HEADER_TRUSTED_PROXIES. Otherwise the address of the proxy in front is used for rate limiting and logs.\n\nSends: bw send receive on CLI 2026.4.2 and older no longer works, the same as against Bitwarden's own servers since v2026.8.0. Creating and managing Sends works on all clients.\n\nFeature flags: these flags were removed because no client reads them anymore: ssh-agent, ssh-key-vault-item, mutual-tls, anon-addy-self-host-alias, simple-login-self-host-alias, pm-25373-windows-biometrics-v2, pm-26340-linux-biometrics-v2, desktop-ui-migration-milestone-1 to -4, cxp-import-mobile and cxp-export-mobile. If EXPERIMENTAL_CLIENT_FEATURE_FLAGS still lists one of them, startup logs a warning and saving settings in the admin panel fails until it's removed.\n\nDuo: DUO_USE_IFRAME (the deprecated Traditional Prompt) is removed and ignored if set.\n\nCustom templates: there's a new email template, email/recover_twofactor, sent after a login with a two-step recovery code.\n\nThe legacy POST /identity/accounts/register and POST /api/accounts/prelogin endpoints are removed. No current client uses them.\n\nWhen using a MariaDB or MySQL server which does not support native TLS/SSL encrypted connections, using the Alpine image of Vaultwarden might fail to connect. Add MARIADB_TLS_DISABLE_PEER_VERIFICATION=1 as an environment variable to your Vaultwarden server environment, and it will start running again.\n\nWhat's Changed\n\n[Web 2026.9.0] Support the vault banner policy by @tom27052006 in #7748\n\nAdd support for basic auth response client feature flag by @tom27052006 in #7745\n\n[web-v2026.8.1] store the user key ID by @Timshel in #7693\n\nAdd organizationsNew and policiesNew to sync response by @tom27052006 in #7666\n\nAdd pm-32009-new-item-types feature flag by @bdd in #7478\n\nUpdate Crates, GHA and JS by @BlackDex in #7751\n\nAdd pm-34171-card-scanner feature flag by @bdd in #7477\n\nset user_created bool for each separate invitation by @stefan0xC in #7753\n\nFix revoked org members retaining access to org ciphers by @abhiShandy in #7554\n\nEnsure all user checked routes are confirmed by @dani-garcia in #7763\n\nFix cortex-a53 build issues when using xx-cargo by @BlackDex in #7774\n\nAdd undetermined-cipher-scenario-logic feature flag (closes #7801) by @cad0p in #7802\n\nAdd Windows native credential sync to supported feature flags by @KingIronMan2011 in #7798\n\nHide the whole change-email section when EMAIL_CHANGE_ALLOWED is false by @tom27052006 in #7759\n\nFix Clippy warnings across all targets by @tom27052006 in #7782\n\nAdmin reset: 2fa email fallback need a verified email by @Timshel in #7770\n\nSends cleanup: remove legacy endpoints and align with upstream by @dani-garcia in #7806\n\nRemove legacy API endpoints and compatibility code by @dani-garcia in #7809\n\nAlign API with upstream and remove unwraps by @dani-garcia in #7810\n\nUpdate cra","url":"https://github.com/dani-garcia/vaultwarden/releases/tag/1.37.4","published_at":"2026-10-06T11:30:54Z","updated_at":null,"fetched_at":"2026-11-22T13:40:16.224741Z","severity":"high","cvss_score":8.1,"epss":null,"is_kev":false,"has_exploit":false,"kev_due_date":null,"vendor":"dani-garcia","product":"vaultwarden","vuln_id":"GHSA-69q9-v8p6-xvx3","vuln_ids":["GHSA-64MC-4P6F-R7X9","GHSA-69Q9-V8P6-XVX3","GHSA-7CCC-C43J-4P36","GHSA-7JG8-8M5X-6J9R","GHSA-Q5X6-GRH5-FQGC","GHSA-QWX4-WCV4-MPCV","GHSA-V576-3WVQ-XH3C"],"tags":["release","repo:dani-garcia/vaultwarden","security"],"cluster_id":11344,"links":{"self":"https://vulnwatch.ve1ve2.com/api/v1/items/12065","html":"https://vulnwatch.ve1ve2.com/item/12065"}}]}